
The Supreme Federal Court (STF) has declared unconstitutional a Paraíba state law that demands proof of income and public school attendance for Black candidates to qualify for racial quotas in public job competitions. The ruling, issued during a virtual session on Friday, overturns a lower court decision and alters Brazil’s approach to affirmative action policies.
The law, known as Law 12.169/21, reserves 20% of state job openings for Black applicants but adds two conditions: candidates must have completed at least one year of high school in a public institution and prove a family income no higher than 1.5 times the minimum wage. The Rede Sustentabilidade party contested these provisions, claiming they distort the reparative intent of racial quotas by linking eligibility to economic status.
Court rejects linking racial quotas to income
The core dispute revolves around whether racial discrimination operates separately from economic or educational barriers. The majority opinion, authored by Ministers Edson Fachin, Flávio Dino, and Cármen Lúcia, argued that racism affects Black individuals regardless of financial or academic background. Fachin emphasized that structural racism persists through institutional biases, stereotypes, and systemic exclusion, rendering income or schooling thresholds ineffective for addressing racial inequality. His statement highlighted that “affirmative action policies structured around economic criteria fail to adequately confront the specific barriers created by structural racism. Race and income represent distinct dimensions of social inequality.” This position aligns with prior STF jurisprudence recognizing racial discrimination as a distinct form of oppression, not merely a consequence of poverty.
The dissenting view, led by Relator Nunes Marques and joined by Dias Toffoli, defended the law’s constitutionality. They argued that the additional criteria were meant to prioritize the most vulnerable Black candidates, acknowledging that economic hardship can worsen the effects of racial discrimination. Marques referenced ADPF 186, a precedent upholding racial quotas without explicitly prohibiting socioeconomic filters. The majority, however, rejected this reasoning. Dino noted that while racial and economic inequalities often overlap, they are not interchangeable. He cited ADPF 973, where the STF formally recognized systemic racism in Brazil, and argued that the law’s income and schooling requirements effectively excluded segments of the Black population from the protections meant to address their marginalization.
Related Post: Supreme Court to Hear Major Cases on Abortion Rights, Guns, and More in Historic Tuesday Session!
The vote concluded with a 3 to 2 decision striking down the Paraíba law’s additional requirements. The full judgment is scheduled for completion by November 10, when the virtual session concludes. The Attorney General’s Office (AGU) had previously supported the plaintiffs, arguing that the requirements violated constitutional equality principles. In contrast, the Paraíba state government and legislature defended the law, claiming it targeted those in greatest need. The STF’s ruling now shifts attention to whether racial quotas can coexist with other affirmative action measures—or if they risk becoming exclusionary rather than inclusive.
Future of quotas hinges on strict criteria
The case does not address the 20% racial quota itself, though the court left open the possibility of maintaining broader social quotas, separate from racial ones. Fachin’s vote suggested a more flexible approach to affirmative action, provided policies do not conflate criteria in a way that undermines their primary objectives. The ruling’s final judgment will determine whether the Paraíba law’s requirements violate Brazil’s constitutional non-discrimination principles. While the majority rejects socioeconomic filters for racial quotas, it does not bar states from implementing separate affirmative action measures targeting economic vulnerability.
Nunes Marques’ dissent presented an alternative interpretation, arguing that the Paraíba legislature acted within constitutional limits by prioritizing Black candidates facing compounded disadvantages. He cited ADPF 186, which allowed racial quotas to include socioeconomic or educational benchmarks if they served a clear public purpose. Marques contended that the law’s income and schooling thresholds were not arbitrary but designed to amplify support for those most affected by overlapping forms of exclusion. Unlike the AGU, the Public Prosecutor’s Office (PGR) had initially supported the law’s validity, framing the requirements as a way to refine, not broaden, affirmative action efforts.


