Sunday, 22 November 2026 Login

Justice. Rights. Recourse.

BREAKING
Victim Advocacy

Germany passes intelligence service reform

Germany passes intelligence service reform - intelligence reform
Bundesinnenminister Alexander Dobrindt argued for stronger agencies.

The German Bundestag has passed a full reform of the country’s intelligence services, a move that has sparked intense debate. The reform aims to strengthen the Bundesnachrichtendienst (BND) and the Bundesamt für Verfassungsschutz (BfV) by granting them new powers to better protect Germany from espionage, terrorism, and sabotage.

Bundesinnenminister Alexander Dobrindt had argued that the intelligence services must become “real intelligence agencies” to effectively counter these threats. He cited examples of planned attacks against German arms managers and operations such as the drone attack on Leipzig/Halle airport. The government justifies the reform by pointing to increased foreign intelligence activities, particularly from Russia, China, and Iran.

Martin Jäger, the president of the BND, warned in October that Russia is waging a “shadow war” against Germany, aiming to intimidate and exploit the country’s weaknesses. The BND and BfV will now have more operative powers, allowing them to intervene in addition to gathering intelligence. This means they can now take actions such as hacking computer systems or destroying dangerous devices or facilities.

Read Also: Block Case: Father Put on Defensive Over Kidnapping Accusations

Criticism and Concerns

The reform has been criticized by civil rights activists and data protectionists, who fear that it could lead to the creation of a new secret police force. They argue that the strict separation between the police and intelligence services is a historical lesson from the National Socialist era, intended to prevent the emergence of a powerful and uncontrolled secret police like the Gestapo. This separation is particularly relevant for the BfV, which operates domestically.

The Bundesverfassungsgericht (BVerfG) had set a deadline for the end of the year to improve the rules for domestic and foreign telecommunications surveillance. The court has repeatedly ordered the legislature to revise the legal framework for the intelligence services in recent years.

The new reform allows the BfV to take “protective measures” such as disrupting the function of weapons or hacking into computer systems. However, it explicitly prohibits the use of direct force against individuals. Section 59 of the Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution Act now permits the BfV to impair the function of explosive devices or weapons, redirect or block data streams in cyberattacks, delete or alter data stored for threats, or provide false information to those involved—though immediate coercion against individuals remains forbidden.

Read Also: Hamm court handles lawyer disputes in NRW

Government Response and Reactions

In response to concerns about a “new secret police,” Interior Minister Dobrindt dismissed the criticism as “absurd” and “historically illiterate,” arguing that the “century-long reform” protects democracy. The SPD, which voted in favor of the reform alongside CDU/CSU, called it a “paradigm shift” in intelligence services. Sonja Eichwede, an SPD member of the Bundestag, emphasized that the reform establishes “real defense services” while maintaining the separation between the BfV and the police.

The Greens took a more differentiated stance. While the party supported the BND law and oversight by the Unabhängige Kontrollrat (UKR), it opposed the law governing the BfV. The Greens criticized the extensive data collection and the use of minors as informants, arguing that the coalition lacks “any sensitivity for civil rights.” Konstantin von Notz, deputy faction leader, called the coalition’s approach “problematic” before the Federal Constitutional Court, though he praised the BND law as “well-crafted” and necessary to strengthen Germany’s first line of defense.

The reform also permits the BfV to secretly enter private residences, such as to retrieve data from devices or disable weapons—a practice that, while previously legal, is now explicitly regulated with high standards and prior approval requirements. Digital capabilities have also been expanded, including the ability to read data from devices (Section 23 of the Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution Act) and monitor telecommunications (Section 22 of the Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution Act).

Tags:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *