
The Brazilian Supreme Court (STF) ruled on October 21, 2026, that the Municipal Service Tax (ISS) is not part of the calculation basis for the Social Integration Program (PIS) and the Social Security Financing Contribution (Cofins). Six justices voted in favor and five against, with Minister Luiz Fux casting the decisive vote.
This decision ends a long-standing dispute that has crossed several compositions of the court, yet it leaves open the question of how the effects of the ruling may be modulated. The judgment also clarifies that amounts that merely pass through a contributor’s accounting do not necessarily constitute revenue or turnover.
The core issue is whether the financial inflow has a definitive character and can be legally qualified as revenue or turnover for the constitutional provision.
In 2017, the STF had already decided that the ICMS – a state tax – does not belong to the PIS and Cofins calculation base because it never becomes part of the taxpayer’s assets. The court explained that the ICMS simply moves through the company’s cash flow on its way to the state and therefore is not revenue under Article 195, I, “b” of the Constitution.
During the Tema 118 case, the majority emphasized constitutional consistency. Although ICMS and ISS have different legal structures, the value linked to the municipal tax does not turn into the service provider’s own wealth merely by being included in the service price. The question decisiva is saber se o ingresso financeiro possui caráter definitivo e se pode ser juridicamente qualificado como receita ou faturamento para os fins daquele dispositivo constitucional.
The Ruling’s Implications
Minister Edson Fachin, the STF’s president, indicated that discussions about modulation should be reserved for possible embargo declarations. Consequently, there is no set timetable for the decision’s entry into force, nor a clear rule on which contributors may recover amounts previously paid.
According to data cited by the PGFN, there are 23,153 actions related to Tema 118 pending nationwide, of which 1,817 have already become final. The agency has asked for a suspension of national judicial and administrative processes concerning the theme until the ruling becomes final.
Related Post: Court Narrows AI Fair Use Precedent in Landmark Ruling
The decision also offers parameters for controversies that will emerge during the transition to the new consumption tax system. The reform modifies the economic dimension of the precedent, as the exclusion of ISS from PIS/Cofins will continue to apply until CBS replaces them, beginning in 2027.
Experience from the earlier Tema 69 case, which also addressed service taxation, suggests a cautious approach. In that matter, the effects were modulated from March 15, 2017, with exceptions for actions filed up to that date. The modulation of Tema 118 will require a qualified quorum of two-thirds, and the exact implementation remains uncertain.
The pendency of the modulation discussion means the ruling’s practical impact remains uncertain. The definition of exceptions for pending judicial or administrative proceedings may alter the scope of recoverable amounts.
On October 22, the PGFN announced its intention to file declarations of opposition to any embargo requests and reiterated that the suspension of national judicial and administrative processes is still under consideration. The agency’s request does not guarantee that the suspension will be granted, leaving the situation still open.
Voting Record and Procedural History of the Decision
The case opened in 2020 and proceeded through several virtual and in-person plenary sessions. At the conclusion, the original rapporteur Celso de Mello’s vote prevailed, joined by Ricardo Lewandowski, Rosa Weber, Cármen Lúcia, André Mendonça, and Luiz Fux. The justices who were outvoted included Dias Toffoli, Gilmar Mendes, Luís Roberto Barroso, Alexandre de Moraes, and Edson Fachin. Votes cast by Celso de Mello, Lewandowski, and Weber were delivered before their retirements and remained valid, so their successors Nunes Marques, Cristiano Zanin, and Flávio Dino did not vote on the merits.
The minority argued that the specific features of ISS could prevent an automatic application of the ICMS solution. It stressed that the two taxes follow distinct incidence and calculation rules, making the objection relevant. Most members, however, relied on the constitutional definition of the contribution base, reasoning that directing the amount to the municipality removes its classification as the company’s own revenue.
Luiz Fux’s vote carried weight beyond the numerical outcome. By aligning with the rapporteur, he reaffirmed the separation between a temporary financial inflow and genuine own revenue, a premise he had previously applied in Tema 69. He also highlighted the need for consistent and integrated jurisprudence. Article 12, §2, V of LC 214/25 excludes ICMS and ISS from the IBS and CBS bases while the two regimes coexist, representing a specific normative choice rather than a universal constitutional rule.
