
The Bar Council has endorsed the Judicial Appointments Commission’s plan to add disability to the equal merit provision used in judge selections, joining ethnicity and gender as criteria that can break a tie between equally-qualified applicants.
Current use and proposed expansion
Under the existing rule, when the commission finds two or more applicants of equal merit, it may give priority to those from under-represented ethnic groups or of a particular gender. In the 2025-26 cycle the body shortlisted 40 individuals and forwarded 14 to the final decision-making stage. The policy is intended to ensure that the shortlist reflects a broader cross-section of society while still rewarding merit.
The Bar Council said the extension should apply both at the shortlisting stage and later when a final choice is made. “We believe that extending EMP to disabled applicants would support the JAC’s statutory duty to encourage diversity in the range of people available for judicial appointment…”, the council said, adding that any use of the rule should be reviewed regularly to confirm its necessity.
Data show that 11% of judges are disabled compared with 18% of the adult working population.
Read Also: Law firm drops founders’ names from title
Consultation results and next steps
A stakeholder consultation, now closed, presented the first published disability data for the bench. The analysis concluded that expanding the rule would likely lead to a small increase in the number of disabled candidates recommended each year. No comparable data were available for sexual orientation, so that characteristic was not part of the discussion. The feedback gathered will be used to fine-tune the final wording of the amendment.
Lord Justice Warby, then a senior judicial commissioner, noted last year that the commission was “actively exploring” the extension. A spokesperson for the body said that the consultation’s feedback would shape forthcoming policy and that the next steps would be published in due course.
Parallel effort to speed up appointments
Separately, the commission is piloting a faster recruitment model across four large judicial selection exercises: deputy district judge, fee-paid judge of the First-tier Tribunal (Immigration and Asylum Chamber), deputy district judge (magistrates’ court), and fee-paid employment tribunal judge. The pilot drops the online scenario test used for shortlisting and refocuses the selection day on role-play exercises with follow-up questions, a change expected to cut timelines by about a quarter. This streamlined format aims to retain a rigorous assessment method that is fair to candidates from all backgrounds while delivering exercises at a greater pace.


