
The High Court has strongly criticised the UK Government Legal Department for repeatedly missing litigation deadlines and ordered indemnity costs to be paid to claimants in a case challenging defence secretary decisions on Afghan nationals seeking relocation to the UK. The court found the department treated procedural directions as optional, assuming the court would excuse defaults without providing adequate justification.
Missed Deadlines and Failed Applications
Mr Justice Chamberlain, who oversees the Administrative Court, noted that by July 2026, the defendant had submitted “very many applications by the defendant for extensions of time to file evidence and other documents, many of them made after expiry of the relevant deadline.” The “first indication” that the defendant would then not be complying with Mould J’s 6 August order in relation to disclosure came after the deadline had passed and it then missed a further deadline set by Mr Justice Fordham. The department failed to meet a late September deadline for filing skeleton arguments and other disclosure materials, applying for an extension four days late-a conduct Chamberlain J described as “a textbook example of bad litigation practice.”
Some of the material had been filed by the time of the hearing before him on 2 October, but the claimants’ counsel said they did not have enough time to go through it and prepare for the 13 October hearing. Chamberlain J observed that the new evidence was substantial and that unilaterally breaching a court order would make the hearing impossible. Despite the defendant’s claim that its team worked with limited resources, the judge found “almost no evidence” to support this, noting that applications for extensions relied on “a few wholly unspecific sentences on the form N244” rather than detailed witness statements.
Related Post: High Court backs car makers in dieselgate case
Costs Ordered and Court’s Response
He ordered the government to pay the claimants’ costs of various hearings caused by the failures, as well as the costs attributable to the adjournment of the substantive hearing that had been fixed for tomorrow, all on the indemnity basis. Further, whatever the outcome of the claims, the government will not be able to recover the costs of preparing the documents filed late in breach of an order by Mr Justice Mould. The effect of this “may be limited” as the claimants were legally aided, “but I have no doubt that it is justified in principle”.
The judge emphasized the negative effect on the court’s “limited administrative and judicial resources,” criticizing the defendant for showing “apparently total lack of planning or organisation” and assuming other parties would adjust their schedules to accommodate delays. He warned that future extension applications must provide “good reasons,” adding that even granted extensions could result in costs orders like those imposed here.
Broader Context and Court Guidance
The ruling follows an Administrative Court practice statement issued in March, which warned that “too many applications for extensions of time are being made at the last minute and/or without proper supporting reasons or evidence, apparently in the belief that the application will not be considered until the applicant has had the extra time sought, so the extension will become a fait accompli.” This case exemplifies that pattern, with the government’s late applications effectively becoming unavoidable.


