Sunday, 22 November 2026 Login

Justice. Rights. Recourse.

BREAKING
Civil Litigation

High Judicial Fees Block Rural Farmers’ Access to Courts

High Judicial Fees Block Rural Farmers' Access to Courts - judicial fees access
The Brazilian Constitution permits judicial fees under Article 145, II, for the exercise of police powers or the use of public services, provided they are specific and divisible.

The right to access the judiciary typically requires paying judicial fees. While these fees fund the state’s judicial services, their amounts are not solely at the discretion of state governments. Constitutional limits apply, especially when fees become barriers to accessing justice. This issue is particularly pronounced in states like Goiás, Tocantins, and São Paulo, where judicial fees can reach high levels based on the value of the disputed claim.

Constitutional Framework and State Disparities

The Brazilian Constitution permits judicial fees under Article 145, II, for the exercise of police powers or the use of public services, provided they are specific and divisible. Article 77 of the National Tax Code defines the criteria for such fees. These fees must be specific and divisible, meaning they must correspond to a specific, individually applicable state service provided to the taxpayer. When fees shift from remunerating a specific state service to primarily generating revenue, their compatibility with constitutional principles must be examined.

It ensures that judicial fees must relate reasonably to the state’s activity and not create disproportionate obstacles to the right of access to justice, guaranteed by Article 5, XXXV. However, disparities between states arise due to the absence of national parameters for setting judicial fee ceilings. Each state sets its rates with near-total autonomy, leading to significant differences in costs for similar cases.

Rural Debt Restructuring Cases as a Test Case

The issue is especially critical in rural debt restructuring cases. These lawsuits seek to recognize a farmer’s right to renegotiate credit due to crop losses, market price changes, or commercialization difficulties. The claim’s value is based on the outstanding debt, which can reach millions of reais. However, the farmer may lack the resources to pay the full amount, making the required judicial fee a barrier to accessing the court.

Read Also: Clinics face liability risks even without doctor fault in Brazil

For example, in Goiás, the State Tax Code’s Article 114-B caps judicial fees at R$ 146,383.54, which may be demanded upfront in high-value cases. This can create a paradox where a farmer unable to pay their debt may face a fee burden disproportionate to their capacity, potentially obstructing access to justice. The fee shifts from a service charge to an economic barrier, violating constitutional principles of equality and access to justice.

Judicial Fees in High-Value Rural Debt Cases

Rural debt restructuring cases highlight how judicial fees can impede access to justice. However, this requirement creates a barrier for farmers who cannot afford the upfront costs. The legal basis is the recognition of a statutory right to credit restructuring, not economic gain.

Legal Criteria for Judicial Fees

The National Tax Code establishes that judicial fees must be specific and divisible. This means the service must be individually applicable to each taxpayer, separable from other state activities. When fees shift from servicing judicial processes to generating revenue, their constitutionality requires scrutiny. The Constitution requires that fees maintain a reasonable relationship with the state’s activity and not assume a confiscatory or disproportionate character that obstructs access to justice.

Judicial Review and Constitutional Safeguards

The Supreme Federal Court has recognized that judicial fees must not reach levels that render access to justice impossible. The jurisprudence of the Court also establishes that fees must maintain a reasonable link to the state’s activity and not create disproportionate barriers to the right of action, requiring analysis of their practical impact. This requires examining not just the legality of the fee structure but its practical impact on the right to sue. In rural debt restructuring cases, for instance, fees calculated on the full debt amount-potentially millions of reais-may conflict with the producer’s inability to pay, as these lawsuits seek to renegotiate unpayable obligations.

Tags:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *