
The recent debate over the victim’s role in the inquérito policial highlights how Brazil’s criminal procedure still deals with outdated provisions from the 1941 code.
Judicial Oversight of Police Inquiries
Article 3º-A states that the magistrate should not intervene in the investigative phase, yet the Supreme Court has clarified that a criminal judge may, in a supplementary manner, order evidentiary steps during the inquiry (ADIns 6.298-6.305, 24 Aug 2023). This reading aligns with the constitutional duty to preserve legality and morality in public administration, as stated in art. 37, CF/88.
The inquérito policial is defined as an administrative procedure aimed at uncovering the material facts and clues to authorship (art. 5º, do CPP). It serves both the holder of the criminal action and the defense, seeking truth rather than a predetermined conviction (art. 5º, LVII, CF/88).
Under the current framework, the judge of guarantees oversees the legality of the investigation and safeguards individual rights (art. 3º-B, do CPP). The same provision also empowers the judge to order the initiation of an insanity incident (art. 3º-B, XIII, do CPP), demonstrating that judicial activity is not wholly barred.
When police or the public prosecutor omit relevant evidence, the judge of guarantees can still compel its collection (art. 156, par. único, II, do CPP). This includes indispensable forensic examinations such as the body-of-evidence analysis (art. 158, caput, do CPP), which the judge may order ex officio.
In cases of violence against women, children, the elderly or persons with disabilities, the law imposes a priority on such measures (art. 158, I-II, do CPP). The victim’s attorney may request additional diligences under art. 14, do CPP, and the offended party may file a writ of mandamus when a clear right to proof is denied.
If an inquiry is prematurely archived, the prosecutor’s error can be challenged through art. 28, do CPP, allowing the court to order further investigative acts. A faulty administrative review that ignores the right to evidence also opens the door to a writ of security, protecting the offended party’s essential rights.
In practice, this may mean that victims can appeal directly to a judge to obtain missing forensic reports or witness statements, rather than waiting for a trial to address evidentiary gaps. Such access may help prevent the loss of time-sensitive evidence and give the injured party a more active role in shaping the factual record.
The Constitution reinforces this protection: denying the victim the procedural safeguards of the inquiry (art. 5º, LIV, CF/88) and blocking judicial review of prosecutorial actions (art. 5º, XXXV, CF/88) constitute clear violations of individual rights.
Related Post: Supreme Court Limits Private Actions Under Investment Act Provision
Systemic issues like police corruption, misinterpretations of the public prosecutor’s power, and procedural bureaucracy continue to undermine these guarantees, even as legislation expands protection for vulnerable groups.
Courts may need to apply a stricter technical standard when evaluating writs of security that aim to preserve the legal order and the rights of those who have suffered a crime, as provided in art. 5º, LXIX, CF/88. The next step may involve granting the victim and their counsel access to jurisdiction and judicial control over the legality of the investigative phase, as provided in art. 5º, II and XXXV, CF/88.
Legislative Shortcomings and Doctrinal Insertions
Such insertions of doctrinal language into statutory text have drawn criticism for blurring the line between law and interpretation. The bankruptcy statute, for instance, includes a provision that ties the existence of a judicial decree to the punishability of certain crimes, thereby creating uncertainty about the temporal scope of criminal liability.
This wording, originally intended for civil recovery, now functions as a penal condition without clear justification, prompting scholars to question its compatibility with the principle of legal certainty.
Consequently, the criminal code’s reliance on labels rather than substantive organization generates practical contradictions. While the code nominally declares an accusatorial framework, other provisions—such as the one governing the dismissal of investigations—appear to limit judicial participation, creating an internal tension.
The presence of article 385, which permits the suspension of procedural acts under specific circumstances, illustrates how contradictory clauses can undermine the proclaimed system, demanding a more coherent legislative design.
Implications for Judicial Practice
Given these inconsistencies, courts are called upon to interpret the code with heightened precision. When faced with a request for evidence that the prosecution has omitted, judges may invoke the authority granted by the singular paragraph of article 156 to order the production of indispensable material, even if the request originates from the victim’s counsel.
Moreover, the judiciary’s capacity to intervene extends to situations involving vulnerable populations. In instances of violence against protected groups, the code provides for priority treatment for forensic examinations, which judges may enforce ex officio.


