
Alternative Business Structures (ABS) transformed the legal environment fifteen years ago, when the first ABS opened its doors. At the time, industry observers compared the prospect of non-lawyers owning law firms to “Tesco Law.” The idea was that supermarkets would sell legal advice alongside cereal packets. In reality, a handful of consumer businesses have entered the market, but the dominant outcome has been greater diversity. ABSs have broken the assumption that there is only one way to build and own a firm. While the traditional partnership model remains dominant for many, it is not the only viable option.
Why the partnership model is no longer the only option
The partnership model has endured for two centuries because it works for many lawyers and firms. However, it limits ownership to legal professionals and concentrates profits among partners. Future investment often competes with the rewards partners take home. ABS reforms introduced a new pathway. They allowed firms to bring in external capital, retain earnings for growth, and include non-lawyers in ownership and management. This shift has enabled firms to take significant financial bets on their future.
Setfords, a firm that became an ABS in December 2014, illustrates this shift. The firm now supports more than 650 self-employed consultant lawyers on its platform, backed by 200 non-lawyer experts in technology and operations. Being an ABS enabled the firm to invest heavily in its own technology and data capabilities. This investment led to the creation of Setfords Technology Solutions, a dedicated team of over 35 technologists.
Related Post: Law firms shift to flexible staffing models
The firm built its own case, accounts, and practice management platform, Halo, and a data foundation called Helix. These tools allow the business to use AI to improve operations. While these investments pay off now, they required capital, specialist expertise, and time that a traditional partnership structure might not have supported as easily.
Recognising that ownership changes can drive service improvements helps explain why ABSs have flourished. New firms and business models have emerged, creating a healthier market. Some have succeeded and some have failed, but consumers have gained more choice. The legal sector now operates with a mix of partnerships, ABSs, listed businesses, platform firms, and unimagined models. The success of the experiment is not that one model replaced another, but that multiple models now exist side by side.
Regulation must focus on outcomes, not structure
As the regulatory framework for legal services is debated once again, regulators should learn from the past fifteen years. Technology is advancing quickly, consumer expectations are rising, and the boundaries between regulated and unregulated services are becoming blurred. These changes justify a review of how legal services are regulated. However, the goal should be to preserve the diversity that ABSs have created. Regulation should be rigorous about professional standards, ethical behaviour, consumer outcomes, and the protection of client money. It should be cautious about prescribing what a law firm ought to look like. Partnerships, ABSs, and other models each play a role. The strength of the legal sector lies in this variety.


